Letter to the Editor: The One Big Beautiful Bill Act: Who really benefits?
Naomi Ludman of Dowagiac writes, “while being described as a pathway to fiscal discipline and a ‘Golden Age,’ this bill instead redistributes wealth upwards and cuts essential public services. These changes could have long-lasting negative effects on everyday Americans.”
To the Editor:
In response to claims that cutting government spending will lead to economic prosperity, it’s vital to look at what this “One Big Beautiful Bill” really does. Rather than offering relief to working families, the bill largely shifts money away from those struggling to make ends meet, and instead it moves the money upward to those in upper income brackets. Analyses show that while many programs designed to help lower-income families are being cut, tax breaks would boost the pockets of top earners and corporations—even as the poorest communities see a decline in their resources. (S. Zhang, Truthout, 5/21/25; D. Hyatt, Investopedia, 5/22/25.)
Fiscal irresponsibility is another huge issue. Rather than really saving money, the projected tax cuts, combined with increased spending included in the bill, are estimated to add nearly $3.8 trillion to the national debt over the next decade. This ballooning deficit means that down the road, cuts and reductions in other vital areas will be forced upon the public. (G. Petras & J. Borrensen, USA Today, 5/21 & 23, 2025; N. Russell, USA Today, 5/22/25)
The impact on healthcare and social services is dire. Essential programs like Medicaid and SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program), which millions rely on for health coverage and food support, will face severe cuts. Instead of creating a more secure future, these policies risk leaving vulnerable populations without a safety net—deepening economic inequality and making it even harder for working families to thrive. (National Health Law Program, 5/22/25; S. Zhang, Truthout, 5/21/25)
In conclusion, while being described as a pathway to fiscal discipline and a “Golden Age,” this bill instead redistributes wealth upwards and cuts essential public services. These changes could have long-lasting negative effects on everyday Americans.
Naomi Ludman
Dowagiac
Any views or opinions expressed in this letter are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the Watershed Voice staff or its board of directors.
Related Articles
Local stories hit the big screen at Kalamazoo Film Society’s fourth annual showcase
The event features mostly filmmakers from Kalamazoo and the surrounding region, with films shot in — and in some cases about — the city itself.
One of the featured filmmakers, Jerod Kauffman, created a documentary about the final days of the longtime dive bar Harvey’s on the Mall, which closed after a buyout. Kauffman said he wanted to capture the story of a place that helped define Kalamazoo’s nightlife culture.
“The closure was sudden to everyone — the community and staff — so I wanted to immortalize a place that was loved by so many,” Kauffman wrote to Watershed Voice. “I saw a fence and bulldozer outside the building today on the way to work. I think it’s going to be torn down, so I am happy I was able to capture a piece of Kalamazoo history and the bar that stood and served the community for 40+ years.”
Useless Creatures to donate all of today’s sales to tornado relief
Useless Creatures Brewing Company plans to donate all sales today, Thursday, March 12 to tornado recovery efforts. All of the money will go to The Huss Project who has been organizing volunteers, collecting donations, and providing resources for those in need in the wake of the tornado.
Sturgis Civic Players to present “Anne of Green Gables” March 20–22 at Sturges-Young Center for the Arts
Directed by Elizabeth Smith of Sturgis and adapted from one of the best-selling books in the world, Anne of Green Gables follows Anne Shirley’s journey from a mischievous girl to a young woman, exploring themes of imagination, belonging, and family.
This production spans six years of Anne’s life — from her arrival in Avonlea as a 12-year-old to her young adulthood at 18 as she prepares to set out on her own. The production highlights many of the story’s most beloved moments.
